@Natural Order: I always considered it to be some kind of a green Tinker, so I didn't understand the unban in the first place. However, the council had the balls to give it a try and, even more importantly, the balls to admit it was a mistake. -> OK.
@Top: I completely disagree with the ban and do not think that many arguments brought up for the ban are entirely valid. However, I will not go into details here. We had this discussion a couple of times - no need to repeat it here. (And no point of doing so.) It got the axe, so that's that.
What I really find curious is the watchlist update. Half the storm deck is on the watchlist... why? Looking at recent results, I don't see that the deck is oppressive at all. Yawgmoth's Will on the watchlist? Sure, the card's effect is ridiculous, however in most decks it's just a bad Regrowth and therefore almost only Storm uses this card. All that + considering that Storm just lost a very important card with Sensei's Divining Top.
(Disclaimer: I don't mean to test everything, obviously. Sol Ring and such stuff are so broken, we don't have to test it to know that such cards are bad for the format.)
@Top: I completely disagree with the ban and do not think that many arguments brought up for the ban are entirely valid. However, I will not go into details here. We had this discussion a couple of times - no need to repeat it here. (And no point of doing so.) It got the axe, so that's that.
What I really find curious is the watchlist update. Half the storm deck is on the watchlist... why? Looking at recent results, I don't see that the deck is oppressive at all. Yawgmoth's Will on the watchlist? Sure, the card's effect is ridiculous, however in most decks it's just a bad Regrowth and therefore almost only Storm uses this card. All that + considering that Storm just lost a very important card with Sensei's Divining Top.
QuoteMost of the argumentation towards reintroducing those dangerous cards into the metagame look like arguments to introduce an invasive species to a healthy ecosystem in the hopes of diversifying it. We all know what usually happens in that case.I do not completely agree here. If we do not test cards in an evolved metagame (to kinda stick to your metaphor), we would never see cards in the format again once they got banned. Remember the unbanning Life from the Loam? The impact was not too large... in fact, did it have any impact at all? But ppl were still remembering Loam-wars and were kinda 'afraid' when the unbanning was announced iirc. Why not test cards for a season and gather some data like it was just done with Natural Order? Trial and error. That's fine with me as long as the council has the guts to admit it didn't work out as expected. But considering the latest decision on Natural Order... they did a good job.
(Disclaimer: I don't mean to test everything, obviously. Sol Ring and such stuff are so broken, we don't have to test it to know that such cards are bad for the format.)