Dear Highlander-Community,
I am following the board almost a decade by now (phew i am getting old -.-)
Anyway I am struggling with Deck selection for my favorite format: European Highlander.
What did I try so far:
- Mono U Artifact Control (2009-2013)
- GWB Rock (2009-2013)
- Orzhov Lifegain/Discard (2010-2012
- Naya Tokens (2014-2019)
- Sultai Reanimator (2019)
- Jeskai Tempo (2019)
- Temur Midrange (2019)
- GWB Pattern Rector (2019)
These decks were either fun decks without competitive effort or are outclassed by other decks (4Color Blood > Zoo) or are to slow with their combo (f.e. GWB Pattern Rector).
I am not really happy respectively long-lasting interested in tweaking, fixing and optimizing any of these.
While following the https://mtgdecks.net/Highlander I have the feeling most of the decklists of unpopular archetypes are outdated.
Is there anything like an general archetype overview/metagame Breakdown besides the yearly Continental Cup?
Maybe I am looking for an "Eierlegende Wollmilch Sau" (~Jack of all trades) but I am searching for a fun Highlander which supports interactive play (not restricted to discard or counter), includes
G-in its mana base and plays something inbetween aggro and midrange ultimately with some little combos or even a chance of luck combo-like finish (f.e. 1-off without much tutoring strong anyway but combo-finish possible).
Does the Swarm have any ideas?(I am not looking for Decklists more than ideas for archetypes)
Thanks in advance
I face a similar problem atm.
I tested GB-Rock, GWB-Mid and Rock, Jeskai and 4c Blood in my 2 years playing this format and watched countless people play various decks.
Nothing seemed to fit for me.
I have noticed that you did not try Bant-Mid.
I am building a version myself atm and it seems to be what fixes my problem.
Bant can be very interactive, agressive, comboy and even controly/tempoy.
The new prints of cards like Oko or Questing Beast and even the new Heliod work pretty well in Bant mid.
The continental showed that GWu can be a pretty good contender for the TOP 8 in various forms.
We saw staxy bant, aggroy bant, midrangy bant.
I do think that a midrange version of bant is pretty strong atm.
Value cards, interaction(counterspells), combo-material (Heliod, Walking Balista, Archangel of Thune + Spike Feeder (works with heliod too) and good tutors for it. You can even try scapeshift with Field of the Dead and Dark Depth stuff. Bant is a playground atm that wants to be tested in my oppinion :)
Hope that helped a litte.
I will follow this threat closely. Maybe someone with more experience can help me out too.
Thanks for your opinion.
Actually I was thinking kind of the same things:
I am flirting with Temur and Bant in a Tempo/Midrange Build.
I am unsure that Midrange is the place to be against mostly Tempo and Control Strategies. You might have game against everythin but it is always more like a coin flip.
Are there any opinions on what archetypes are good vs Elfball or Goblin-Highlander (Swarm with Tokens, Combo into Craterhoof etc or addition Goblins burn opponent out respectively flood board out of nowwhere and attack/Sac for lethal)?
I think a more controlling build would be a good option. Am I wrong?